
All too often the story repeats itself, again and again and again. And now there are reports out that say “Spain is losing productivityâ€? year by year…some are even calling us “the lazy bonesâ€? of Europe. Where else can you go on holiday for a month, to say nothing of the weeks of vacation most can take at Easter or Christmas time? Uh oh, aren’t we forgetting the extra three or four days to celebrate our town’s patron saint… and what about our “nationalâ€? holidays?
How many days a year do you really work? Time to get out the calculator, and start comparing our timetable or schedules with everyone else. Okay, for starters, there are 52 weeks in a year, and five working days,(for most of us). But then again, maybe those 5 days are really 4 ½ days. So now let’s do the math: 4.5×52= 234 days. Now let’s subtract vacation time (20 days), national holidays (+/- 14 days), and oh yes, the other 2 or 3 days for our town saints or regional heroes. Now we are at the 199-198 day mark. So there are 365 days in a year, so we are working exactly 54% of the year.
Is Spain alone on this? Probably not, but ALMOST! Yes, there are other European countries where people take long holidays, but they are not suffering the same loss of productivity. This is probably because they are countries that have learned the beauty (or ugliness) of 24-hour shops with day and night shifts, working on Saturdays, etc. to make up for time lost.
Is there something wrong here? The average Spaniard has started to work longer and longer office hours, while “business� hours do not change. This means that unless your bank, your company, etc has changed their business hours, they are probably not making more money (nor paying you more money) to keep their doors open. So even if you put more hours in, you are never going to see the fruits of a longer workday.
Many contend that it’s not TIME but a question of the QUALITY OF TIME, or the effectiveness with which you do your job. Okay, now you are going to hate me for this, but I am going to repeat the same thing over and over again: Look at the Germans, the English, the Americans, etc. They all have 5-day work weeks, and after you have been working a while, you may even have three weeks of vacation, but what do they do that’s different? While they are in the office, they actually work! When the whistle blows at five o’clock you are out the door! Your boss kicks you out of the office! And if you haven’t finished your work…well, you have not been as productive as you should have been!
Now, don’t compare us to the Americans and the Germans, or the Brits: SPAIN IS DIFFERENT! Spain is different, but if you are looking for productivity, look at your nearest success stories and instead of getting jealous, do what they’re doing! This is like the old story about the young boy who says to his mother, “Mum, I can’t figure out why my watch doesn’t work, I already took it apart and washed it with soap and water three times!â€? Time for some self-criticism to reach some real solutions before we fall behind.
Released under the following licence: Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDeriv
You are free to copy, distribute and display the contents of this article but you must give credit to and mention the original author. You are not allowed to use these contents for commercial purposes, and you may not modify them to make any derivative works.
For full licence description, go to: http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/2.1/es/deed.en
Posted on http://www.weeklyletter.com at 2006-07-24 02:01:00 +0200
Copyright (C) ITT (http://www.itt.es) and Planet Lingua (http://www.lingua.es)
We have more weekly letters by Paul
Spain IS productive!
You are free to copy, distribute and display the contents of this article but you must give credit to and mention the original author. You are not allowed to use these contents for commercial purposes, and you may not modify them to make any derivative works.
(click the above link for more information)
Add a comment
Good evening everyone.
I think we spend our most productive hours of the day in the office (since we need at least 7 to sleep), therefore already we work enough.
It is a cultural question. The average Spaniard use to spend at least two hours to eat, in other countries they don´t sit down to eat two dishes and a dessert. This make that the hours in the office last too much. Moreover, companies use to promote the number of hours that you remain in the office, they don’t bear in mind you results and productivity.
On the other hand let’s not forget that there are workers, as taxi drivers, plumbers, waiters, etc ( they have their own bussines) who do not have schedule.
P.D Spain is different and we try to keep our holidays. One secret, I’m writing this from my desk in the office.
Happy holidays for those will celebrate St. Santiago tomorrow !! ( Spanish patron saint)
Angel C
Excellent comments Angel!
Yes, Spain really is different. Where else can you walk down the street with a glass of booze in your hand and have a policeman come up to you and ask you where he can get one too! LOL!!!!!
I don’t think there are many of us who have the pleasure of more than an hour lunch, especially in Madrid. Management is constantly cutting our days in half on purpose, making us stay at the office because they mandated an hour and a half lunch which people NEVER take any more! It’s totally unfair!
Happy ST JAMES! (SANTIAGO!) To all of YOU! Long live SPAIN!
Every country in Europe has at least a month of holidays. Denmark (other European countries, too!), for example, has five weeks, even more than we do. And it is constantly on the lists of best places in the world to live (Best places) and doesn’t exactly have “productivity” problems.
And I doubt that many full-time workers, besides us, are working four and a half days a week. Ask anyone who works in a major corporation, a factory or even a bar for that matter. Some would be thrilled to work 40 hours a week, not to mention five days. Working 54% of the year is a dream for all of us, but a reality for few, perhaps some civil servants and part-timers… And in the city centre, banks are open until at least 7 p.m. Try to find a bank in Chicago that will exchange your money for a pre-dinner apéritif.
Shops in Spain don’t and can’t open 24 hours (but they don’t in most of Europe, either). The only ones which have the infrastructure and ability to do that are large shopping centres, supermarkets and chains. Without even going into the topic of globalisation, it is obvious that small shops cannot compete with these corporate giants and frankly, shouldn’t have to. Productivity is based on production. Factories produce. Companies produce. Factories in Spain already have a shift system and are open 24 hours a day. What do you need to buy at 4 a.m., anyway? There’s always a “farmacia de guardia.” Most small food shops open at 8 a.m., then medium supermarkets at 9 and large ones at 10. The latter are open until 10 p.m. Who can’t find time in a 14 hour span to make their purchases, regardless of the place they choose to make them? Spain, quite frankly, has some of the most extended timetables in Europe. Go try to shop in the U.K. at 9 p.m. and see what you can get. Even Harrod’s closes at 7!!! Also, 24 hour shifts make working Sundays and holidays inevitable. At how many American Thanksgivings, Christmases, Easters or even Sunday lunches were family members missing because they had to work. Since I have been here, that has never happened.
I must agree on the time quality concept. In Spain, the idea still exists that quantity is more important than quality. If work were concentrated into less hours, people, especially in big cities, would have more free time to live their lives. But it’s not so easy to change people’s habits. And part of the problem is that there aren’t enough people that are bothered by the way things are. A revolution won’t happen until people truly care and, frankly, I don’t think they do.
Self criticism, indeed…
One last comment: I have a two hour lunch and am quite happy with it.
In fairness to Spain… I think that Spain is a hive of creativity in urban planning and architecture, for example. These related fields alone generate a lot of production AND productivity in a wide range of sectors, from the actual building industry to publishing. It’s been like this for quite some time now, perhaps two decades. All eyes are on Spain. Not all countries get the international critical acclaim in these fields that Spain does. Spain is hot. Not all countries get the time and space in New York City’s MoMA that Spain has these past few months. Etc. Etc. Etc.
Thanks for your comments Wes!
I am glad you agree with me on productivity in Spain, at least TIME Productivity… I see we both agree about Denmark:”there are other European countries where people take long holidays, but they are not suffering the same loss of productivity. ”
Or in the words of a Copenhagen Business news source “Danish companies’ ability to take out extra value from each working hour is strongly improved, show figures from Conference Board, the international business think tank. Both in 2004 and 2005, Danish companies have increased their hourly working productivity much quicker than in the countries with which we normally compare ourselves, including the USA, which is considered a global leader in productivity, writes Børsen.”
Spain has some of the most extended timetables in Europe? I think you maybe referring to their capacity to go out until the wee hours of the morning…not about work timetables. Most workers that stay in the office are there to “look good” not to work.
I don’t think we need 24-hour stores here in Spain.. I agree with you. On the other hand, it has nothing to do with infrastucture or globalisation at all… it has to do with demand. I am sure those factory workers you were talking about could use a 24-hour store or cafeteria or two to make themselves feel like normal people when they leave work…
Comparing banks in Chicago with Spanish banks? Let’s start comparing the size of mellons and grapes and see who wins…
In essence, quality of life IS more important…we both agree on that! By the way, this all came about from a news item that claimed that Spain was lagging behind the rest of Europe…not my own personal opinion of course…
Excellent comments Gina!
If you are talking about the most lucrative sector in Spain, you have hit the nail on the head! With real estate prices gone through the roof and completely out of control, big real estate and architecture companies are really “raking in the dough”...
Spain “WAS” hot a couple of years ago, ranked the “fastest growing economy of Europe.” And now we are simply losing all sorts of foreign investors, foreign multinationals, etc. that are moving elsewhere… I wonder why?..... food for thought.
Great comments!
Paul
Here’s another interesting article about Spain’s low productivity. In a very general sense, I must admit that the Spaniards are a bit lazy. For example, and this is from a teacher’s point of view, sometimes they never do their homework! :-)
Anyway, I don’t think that Gina was talking about real estate at all. At least not real estate in the mediocre speculation sense. She was talking about architects and architectures of the haute culture and intellectual-muscle kind. The MoMA would never have it otherwise.
I believe you are absolutely right Paola!
It would appear that “productivity” may not matter as much as “artistic value”, such as the beauty of Spanish architecture – Good point!
“Laziness” is the devil’s playground…or is that “idleness”?...
I think that the main reason Spain is so improductive (despite what the poll says), is that there are NO LEADERS behind them that are “pushing them” to get to work. Supervisors do not care about organising their employees time (the way my boss does.) They only want their employees to give them the LEAST amount of problems, the LEAST amount of work, and above all, spend the LEAST amount of time with them… what a mistake!
If work was such a good thing, the rich would have found a way of keeping it for themselves.
:-)
Words of Wisdom Donal…do I sense another rich versus poor analogy coming on? I know you’re right though… In general though it’s safe to say that people who are filthy rich don’t work because their ancestors did it for them!
Some people say that work is the result of original sin, that if Adam hadn’t screwed up in the Garden, we wouldn’t have to work at all…. I wish he would have thought twice before giving in to Eve…but then again, we wouldn’t enjoy Guiness as much afterwards, or would we?